Carbonomics
National and International Energy Policy
Steven  Stoft
Library Papers Printable
 
 
  Home
Carbon Policy Blog
Copenhagen
Waxman-Markey
Wind Power
Hydrogen Economy ♦
Carbon Pricing
 
Hydrogen Economy
 
 
 
Prospects for a Hydrogen Economy -- Slides and Paper
R & D in the U.S. for a Hydrogen Economy.  April, 2008, Madrid, Spain.
4 slides per page PDF.  Same, but 1/page PDF
R & D  Programs for Hydrogen in the US and EU.  December 2008. w/ Cesar Dopazo
This paper basically justifies in advance why Chou and Obama have now done.

Overview: DOE is unlikely to meet its goals for commercial hydrogen-car technology in 2015. Hydrogen will probably not reduce CO2 emissions noticeably for at least three decades.

DOE has made two claims regarding technical progress. (1) Fuel cells could be produced with current technology at a cost of $100/kW, or $2,400 for an 80kW fuel cell for a standard car. (2) Hydrogen fuel stations can provide hydrogen for a cost of $3/kg (equivalent to $3/gallon of gas). The H2 is produced from natural gas with a 70% efficiency.

Both claims are dubious. Fuel cell costs are based on a hypothetical 500,000 unit/year factory, yet not one of these fuel cells has been produced. The H2 fueling station costs were based on selling electric power from spare hydrogen at a retail price of 8 cents/kWh. Only one station is in operation and it had filled H2 tanks less then 10 times when the report was written.

The $100/kW fuel cell had only 1/4 the required durability according to the National Academy, and a $30/kW fuel cell is needed according to DOE. Assuming the actual cost would be at least $200/kW from a real factory, present fuel-cell costs are 2 x 4 x 3.3, or 26 times too high. H2 Fuel tanks do not currently come close to DOE's specifications.
 
 
  References:
Review of the Research Program of the FreedomCAR and Fuel Partnership: Second Report,  From the National Academy of Sciences and Engineering, 2008

Hydrogen Fuel Initiative From the Government Accountability Office, Jan. 2008.

US DOE Hydrogen Posture Plan, December, 2006.

The Hydrogen Economy, from The National Academies, February, 2004.
 
 
  DOE's Main H2 Page
Budget for DOE hydrogen program
DOE's nuclear hydrogen initiative
Guiding documents

DOE's E.Eff.+Renew.E. H2 page

PNL's H2 analysis resource center
Hydrogen Data Book, PNL, DOE
Hydrogen Calculator

NAS 2008 report


Various
California Fuel Cell Partnership
FuelCells.org
National Institue of Standards and Technology
Nat. H2 Association (promotion)
NREL home page
International Assoc. for H energy (1974)
American Hydrogen Association
US Fuel Cell Council
Penn State H2E center


ICE Engine efficiency
Electric Motor efficiency
Electric Motor efficiency
DOE-EERE Electric efficiency
Battery cost
Energy density of everything

 


http://stoft.com/p/26.html | 03/11/10 10:28 GMT
Modified: Sun, 05 Jul 2009 22:12:58 GMT
 
Carbonomics-120w
Amazon
China and India have nixed caps. Without these caps, Kyoto fails. What can be done?
Carbonomics explains "wrecking" the economy, "peak oil," caps, carbon taxes, and Kyoto.
About Carbonomics.
Get discount.